First five rounds: Riley Greene (1-5), Nick Quintana (2-47), Andre Lipcius (3-83), Ryan Kreidler (4-112), Bryant Packard (5-142)
Also notable: Cooper Johnson (6-172), Zack Hess (7-202), Austin Bergner (9-262), Cade Doughty (39-1162)
The Tigers' draft strategy was very clear-cut here. After loading up their farm system with tons of high upside pitchers like Casey Mize, Matt Manning, Alex Faedo, Beau Burrows, Kyle Funkhouser, and Tarik Skubal, they decided to flip the script and grab exclusively hitters this year, taking bats with their first six picks. Between potential lineup-anchor Riley Greene, power bats Nick Quintana, Andre Lipcius, and Bryant Packard, and good defenders like Ryan Kreidler and Cooper Johnson, they really covered their bases. I also really like the seventh round selection of Zack Hess, who could be a fast moving reliever with set-up man or even closer upside. Additionally, they didn't mess around with the bonus pool, signing nine of their first ten picks to exactly slot value deals.
1-5: OF Riley Greene (Hagerty HS [FL], my rank: 6)
While Bobby Witt Jr. garnered a lot of attention as the clear best high school player in the class, Riley Greene might have the best pure high school bat since Brendan Rodgers, who went third overall to the Rockies in 2015 and grew up less than a half hour away. Greene, from the Orlando area like Rodgers, can just flat out hit. He has a big, power producing swing that would typically cause swing and miss issues in most kids his age, but he has exceptional feel for the barrel and still makes consistent hard contact against quality pitching, even against the best arms on the showcase circuit. Add in his excellent plate discipline, and you've got a kid who is probably an even safer bet to hit in pro ball than Rodgers. His raw, batting practice power might not quite stack up with the Brett Baty's or Rece Hinds' of the class, but he's so efficient about getting to it in games that he still projects for 25-30 home runs annually to go along with the high on-base percentages he looks to put up. That gives him the overall outlook of a middle of the order, impact hitter. Defensively, he's just average in left field, but it's the bat the Tigers are buying. Honestly, I see some Juan Soto in him. Committed to Florida, Greene instead signed with the Tigers at slot for $6.18 million and he's slashing .322/.413/.500 with three home runs and a 29/13 strikeout to walk ratio over 23 games between the complex level Gulf Coast League and short season Connecticut.
2-47: SS Nick Quintana (Arizona, my rank: 51)
Nick Quintana was a well-regarded recruit coming out of a Las Vegas high school and ranked #109 on my 2016 draft rankings, then all he did was get better and better each year at Arizona. He had his best year this year, when he slashed .342/.462/.626 with 15 home runs and a 54/45 strikeout to walk ratio over 56 games, including a very strong .313/.434/.661 in-conference in a tough Pac-12 Conference. Quintana is only 5'10" but he hits for plenty of power, and he got to it frequently this year. However, his hit tool is unproven, as his 19.6% strikeout rate was a little high and he also owns a modest .230/.312/.423 line with eleven home runs over two years in the elite Cape Cod League (.259/.351/.435 in the more recent season). There is some length to his swing, though I do think he'll be able to make everything play up in pro ball. Overall, he projects for 25 home runs per season and middling on-base percentages, which still makes him an impact hitter if not a true middle of the lineup guy. The Tigers also picked Quintana up as a shortstop, which seems unlikely given that he played third base for Arizona, but he's a very good defender there and could conceivably move over to shortstop if he can figure out a way to improve his range. Third base is his most likely destination, but he'll certainly be a net-positive there. Quintana signed at slot for $1.58 million and is slashing .210/.286/.290 with a home run and a 34/10 strikeout to walk ratio over 29 games at Class A West Michigan so far.
3-83: 3B Andre Lipcius (Tennessee, unranked)
Like Quintana, Andre Lipcius has hit better and better each year in college. The Williamsburg, Virginia native had his best year this season, slashing .308/.399/.586 with 17 home runs and a 33/31 strikeout to walk ratio over 61 games for Tennessee and still maintaining a .322/.404/.534 line in SEC play. He also slashed .313/.391/.456 in the Cape Cod League this past summer, showing that his production plays up against advanced competition. Lipcius has a big, whippy swing that produces a lot of power, but he managed to keep his strikeout rate down at just 11.9%, which is certainly an encouraging sign for a kid with his profile. Still, the strikeouts will be important to watch as he moves through the minors, but in all he has similar offensive upside to Quintana. However, the two differ on defense despite playing the same position, as Lipcius is extremely slow and has limited range at third base despite a strong arm. He may be able to stick there if he continues to improve, but with Quintana likely to end up as the third baseman down the line and the two expected to follow similar timelines, first base is a serious possibility, which will put pressure on the bat. Lipcius signed at slot for $733,100 and is slashing .267/.331/.345 with a home run and a 26/10 strikeout to walk ratio through 30 games with Quintana at West Michigan, interestingly seeing some time at second base.
4-112: 3B Ryan Kreidler (UCLA, unranked)
With guys like Michael Toglia, Chase Strumpf, and Garrett Mitchell around you in the lineup for the #1 team in college baseball for most of the season, it's easy to slip under the radar even with good performance. Ryan Kreidler slashed .300/.370/.502 with nine home runs and a 52/26 strikeout to walk ratio over 63 games for the Bruins, though those numbers dipped slightly to .282/.336/.470 in conference games in the Pac-12. He's 6'4" and that helps him hit for some power, but with the dip his numbers took in conference and the .229/.300/.339 line he put up on the Cape, he has something to prove in pro ball. His plate discipline is so-so and he's more of a line drive hitter anyways, so he'll have to take a step forward with his ability to barrel up the ball with loft if he wants to eventually reach average power. Overall, that's an offensive outlook of 10-15 home runs per season with middling on-base percentages, so more of a utility infielder projection. Defensively, he's quite good, as he has both the defensive actions and arm to profile anywhere in the infield. He'll get run out as a shortstop, where he has a chance to stick, but he could also be a well above average defender at third base if he ends up there. That will buy the bat some time. The Davis, California native signed at slot for $517,400, and he is slashing .253/.362/.356 with a home run and a 26/11 strikeout to walk ratio over 24 games at Connecticut.
5-142: OF Bryant Packard (East Carolina, my rank: 109)
When he's going right, Bryant Packard can really hit. As a sophomore at ECU in 2018, he slashed .406/.462/.671 with 14 home runs, then went on to slash .305/.421/.576 with four home runs and a 17/12 strikeout to walk ratio over 18 games on the Cape. However, he took a small step back in 2019 and finished at .358/.444/.550 with seven home runs and a 44/29 strikeout to walk ratio over 58 games, still great numbers but comparably pedestrian against his 2018 season. His streakiness might stem from his long swing and so-so plate discipline, and he struck out in 17.1% of his plate appearances this year. He seems like the kind of guy where pro coaching could turn him around, as that Cape line shows that he's not afraid of advanced pitching and the power he packs in his 6'3" frame is very real. Defensively, the Greenville, North Carolina native isn't much, so he'll have to hit to move up. He signed at slot for $386,600 and is slashing .328/.380/.500 with two home runs and an 18/6 strikeout to walk ratio over 18 games between Connecticut and West Michigan.
6-172: C Cooper Johnson (Mississippi, unranked)
Cooper Johnson has had an interesting career trajectory. A top prospect out of high school in the Chicago area, he had a shot to go on Day One of the 2016 Draft and ranked 73rd on my list that year. However, he was unsignable and packed it up for Ole Miss, where he slashed just .213/.301/.269 as a freshman and .235/.329/.324 as a sophomore. Heading to the Cape after both seasons, he combined to hit just .145/.275/.145 over 32 games. However, while he didn't quite get his stock back to where it was three years ago, Johnson managed to right the ship a bit this year and finished at a respectable .271/.371/.449 with eight home runs and the same 44/29 strikeout to walk ratio as Packard over 63 games. Perhaps most importantly, he maintained those numbers in SEC play, where he slashed .284/.373/.431. He starts with his hands up over his head at the plate, and he uses his uppercut swing to hit for average power when he's able to get into one. However, the swing is still somewhat long and outside of his decent numbers in SEC play this year, he's completely unproven against higher level pitching. That's okay for now, because he's a catcher with a cannon arm who can handle himself behind the plate. He has a very good chance to stick back there and if he can continue the progress he made in 2019 and find the barrel consistently in pro ball, he could be a backup catcher at the big league level. Johnson signed at slot for $291,400, and he's slashing .226/.355/.306 with a 20/12 strikeout to walk ratio over 19 games between Connecticut and West Michigan.
7-202: RHP Zack Hess (LSU, my rank: 90)
Ah, the good ole' premium arm with premium stuff who just hasn't gotten results. Zack Hess was draft eligible as a sophomore at LSU last year and ranked 102nd on my list, but he elected to go back to Baton Rouge to try to bump up his stock after his 5.05 ERA that year. However, this year was more of the same as he bounced between the rotation and the bullpen for the LSU, and he finished with a 4.71 ERA, a 1.63 WHIP, and an 82/35 strikeout to walk ratio over 70.2 innings. The Lynchburg, Virginia native is a 6'6" righty with a ton of arm strength, firing his fastball in the low to mid 90's as a starter and bumping it to the upper 90's in relief. He also hurls a plus slider that is devastating in short spurts, though his lack of a changeup caused it to play down in the rotation. Hess also has awkward mechanics and has battled his command throughout his time in Baton Rouge, so his new Tigers organization is going to need to smooth him out there. Honestly, I see no reason for Detroit to try him as a starter at all, and they should just stick him in the bullpen and let him rocket to the majors. Though he's a junior, he turned 22 in February and is the age of a senior, so the bullpen thing becomes even better of an idea. Hess signed at slot for $227,700 and he has a 2.53 ERA, a 1.03 WHIP, and a 15/7 strikeout to walk ratio over 10.2 innings between complex ball, Connecticut, and West Michigan, where he has worked exclusively in relief.
9-262: RHP Austin Bergner (North Carolina, unranked)
Bergner, like a lot of the guys the Tigers drafted this year, was well-regarded in high school, but he opted to attend UNC instead. Draft eligible as a sophomore, he elected to return for his junior year, where he had a 4.94 ERA, a 1.49 WHIP, and a 77/31 strikeout to walk ratio over 82 innings. The Orlando-area native sits in the low to mid 90's with his fastball and adds a very good changeup that can really miss bats when he locates it, though his curveball is more average to a bit below. His command comes and goes and he can get hit hard when it's not on, and with the effort with which he throws and his age (turned 22 in May), he might be better off in the bullpen. However, if the Tigers are willing to be patient, they could make him a #4 or #5 starter if he refines his curve and command. Bergner signed at slot for $157,200 and has a 7.20 ERA, a 1.50 WHIP, and a 9/4 strikeout to walk ratio over ten innings between complex ball and Connecticut.
39-1162: SS Cade Doughty (Denham Springs HS [LA], my rank: 81)
With a talent level that had him in the second or third round, Cade Doughty fell to the 39th because of signability and he'll make the short trip down I-12 to LSU for school. The Baton Rouge-area high schooler has very good bat to ball skills and feel for the barrel, a semi-projectable frame at 6'1", and enough whip in his swing to have some power projection. His mechanics aren't the most consistent at this point, but he finds the barrel often enough that he should be able to transition fairly smoothly to whatever tweaks the Tigers (the LSU kind) make. He's also a very good defender at third base, and he could also handle second base or the outfield. I find him very interesting and he could make an immediate impact on the LSU program.
No comments:
Post a Comment