The Red Sox took a very interesting path with their bonus pool money, shaping up for a funky but interesting class. It is clear the team was infatuated with Jake Schaffner, widely projected as a second round talent, but that they did not want to risk his not being available at their next pick at #67. Rather than sweat it out, they got their guy and gave him far, far less than slot value, using those savings to pry Jace Mataczynski (Auburn), Martin Shelar (Mississippi State), and Kaleb LaFavor (Iowa) away from expensive college commitments. Essentially, based off bonus values they traded one first round pick for three second round picks. With the savings, they were able to have a little bit of fun in the back half of the draft. Where most teams dole out $150K signing bonuses to their favorite leftovers, the Red Sox were able to give four bonuses slightly above that $150K number (coming from the bonus pool) and get Deluxe™leftovers, always a nice little addition. Looking across the class, it's very clear that Boston prioritized athleticism and loud tools in its bats, while many of its arms are model-friendly with significant optimization upside. Boston could end up doing very well for itself with this group.
Full index of team reviews here. Full rankings here.
Note that the number before a player's name indicates their draft position. For example, "2-50" would indicate that a player was taken in the second round with the fiftieth overall pick.
Slot value: $4.37 million. Signing bonus: $2 million ($2.37 million below slot value).
My rank: #61. MLB Pipeline: #75. ESPN: #51.
When the Red Sox spent their first pick on Jake Schaffner, widely projected firmly in the second round range, it was a shock. Looking at the signing bonus, it looks like it may be a very prudent play. Schaffner signed for far, far less than slot value, his $2 million bonus coming in at less than half and fitting just over the value of the #50 pick, so the Red Sox were able to take that $2.37 million in savings and spread it around later in the class. And most importantly with this pick, they got their guy. He began his career at North Dakota State, where he was First Team All-Summit League in both 2024 and 2025 while hitting a .353 across 103 games up on the prairie. Transferring nearly 1200 miles to UNC, he had zero issues with the transition to ACC pitching and hit .353 for the Tar Heels, including a blistering .370 against high level pitching in conference play. He is an elite contact hitter who rarely swings and misses even against advanced pitching, including hitting .281 with an excellent .391 on-base percentage in the competitive Cape Cod League last summer, showing an excellent eye and feel for the barrel. Utilizing a crouched setup and a gashing left handed swing geared for line drive contact, he has below average power and will likely top out at 10-15 home runs per season in a best-case scenario barring major changes to his approach. He's not a pure slap hitter, though, and can turn on the ball to keep pitchers honest. The Wisconsin native is a plus runner and a great athlete, showing all the glovework necessary to stick at shortstop long term. His arm is more of a question, though, and he probably fits better as a second baseman in an ideal scenario. Schaffner could be a plus defender at the keystone and steal plenty of bases. The upside here is an annual .300 hitter who flirts with .400 on-base percentages, swats 10-15 home runs per season, and racks up the stolen bases, making for a true leadoff type if everything goes right.
Slot value: $1.32 million. Signing bonus: $1.2 million ($117,300 below slot value).
My rank: #78. MLB Pipeline: #67. ESPN: #62.
Make that back to back guys who traded green and gold for Carolina blue. Owen Hull began his career at George Mason, where he barely played as a freshman before breaking out to slash .367/.474/.557 as a sophomore, earning his opportunity at UNC. There, like Jake Schaffner, he tore the cover off the ball despite the jump in competition and hit .393/.500/.615 across 69 games, including a staggering .418/.500/.648 in conference play. Hull has a funky left handed swing that he deploys effectively, hitting the ball hard in all directions while limiting chase and swing and miss. He mostly just throws his hands at the baseball and lets the barrel whip behind it, creating sneaky torque with his 6'4" frame to create fringy power that could produce 15-20 home runs per season at peak, though the power comes more from strength than bat speed. Hull has excellent feel for the barrel but can frequently top or get under the ball, hitting it hard into the sky or pounding it into the dirt. A plus runner, the Northern Virginia native has a chance to stick in center field, but his fringy arm will push him to left field rather than right if he does move off the eight. He turned 22 shortly after the draft and is therefore old for a college junior, with the ceiling of a league average bat getting on base with moderate power.
Slot value: $815,700. Signing bonus: $2 million ($1.18 million above slot value),
My rank: #111. MLB Pipeline: #131. ESPN: #77.
The Red Sox began to unload their massive savings on Jace Mataczynski, actually giving him the same $2 million bonus (pick #50 value) as first rounder Jake Schaffner to sign him away from an Auburn commitment. This is a very risky play by Boston, as Mataczynski has much farther to go even than most high schoolers to reach his considerable ceiling. While he wasn't seen much on the showcase circuit, he performed well in his brief looks and caught Boston's eye especially. He was mostly evaluated against cold weather competition in western Wisconsin, just across the border from the Twin Cities, where he performed well but looked raw in many ways. Mataczynski has a noisy operation and doesn't repeat his right handed swing consistently, often getting off balance or out of sync. That said, the sky is the limit once the Red Sox smooth out his operation. He's extremely projectable at 6'4" and when he gets off his A swing, shows great bat speed. The power is presently average but he could add a full grade as he fills out and cleans up his swing, while Boston really believes the hit tool will come around with pro instruction. That's tremendous upside before even getting to the defense. He is a tremendous athlete with plus speed, plus arm strength, and an advanced glove at shortstop, giving him every opportunity to stick there long term and provide significant value too. The whole package is reminiscent of a right handed hitting Colson Montgomery. Boston is taking on significant risk in order to chase this upside with the belief that his raw operation is a product more of amateur instruction than any lack of feel for the game.
Slot value: $454,100. Signing bonus: $350,000 ($104,100 below slot value).
My rank: unranked. MLB Pipeline: unranked. ESPN: unranked.
Lucas Davenport has been around and hasn't quite gotten the results of a high draft pick, but again, Boston sees a development opportunity that could make $350K look like a bargain. He began his career at Texas A&M but never made it into a game, so he transferred to nearby Blinn JC and led the Buccaneers to the NJCAA National Championship in 2024. Transferring a second time to Baylor in 2025, he worked out of the bullpen before transitioning to the rotation in 2026. Though his 6.25 ERA left some to be desired, he showed the stuff and frame for much more. The 6'6", 230 pound right brings the requisite size of a big league pitcher and uses his frame to create great extension and relatively flat approach from a three quarters slot. He moves well with smooth mechanics that help him generate velocity and extension with ease, which also helps him pour in strikes even if his control (ability to throw strikes) is ahead of his command (ability to hit spots in the zone). The fastball sits in the low to mid 90's and touches 98 at peak with run, though the overall movement is average and he relies on his velocity and extension to get results. He has a sweeping slider with some upside, though his feel for it is inconsistent. He splits the difference with a cutter, then also drops in a solid changeup that could be average or better in time. The Red Sox see the size, easy delivery, four pitch mix, and low walk rate (5.7%) and believe they could develop Davenport into a solid back-end starting option. To get there, the Dallas-area product will need to optimize his fastball a little better to miss more bats as well as pick up a little more feel for his secondaries and fine tune his in-zone command a but, but the playbook is there. If he can't check all of that off, the fastball velocity + extension gives him a nice starting point for the bullpen.
Slot value: $205,400. Signing bonus: $1.5 million ($1.29 million above slot value),
My rank: #85. MLB Pipeline: #175. ESPN: #80.
With plenty of bonus pool space left over, the Red Sox unloaded another massive bonus in the ninth round by prying Martin Shelar away from a Mississippi State commitment for $1.5 million, roughly the value of the #62 pick. Like Jace Mataczynski, he comes with plenty of risk and plenty of upside. Already a known commodity down in Atlanta, Shelar bashed his way up boards this spring by leading all U.S. high schoolers with 19 home runs. He is a sturdy 6'2" right handed hitter that takes uppercut swings looking to pull the ball in the air, an approach that worked wonders against strong Atlanta high school pitching. The power is very real, with explosive bat speed and some jaw dropping exit velocities at the MLB Draft Combine in June showing that this could be legitimate plus-plus power we're talking about here. Scouts are more split on the hit tool, as Shelar made plenty of contact during his high school season but may run into problems against more advanced arms in pro ball given his all-out approach. Boston may wish to bring him along slowly as he learns to balance chasing power with a more nuanced approach in pro ball, but they're certainly believers that he'll tap plenty of that power as he moves up the ladder. At ceiling, he seems like a .250 hitter with 30+ home runs annually if all works out. An above average runner, he has a strong arm and profiles nicely in right field, where he should be above average. Shelar is slightly old for a high school senior and turned 19 about a month after the draft.
Slot value: $194,000. Signing bonus: $847,500 ($653,500 above slot value).
My rank: unranked. MLB Pipeline: unranked. ESPN: #171.
The Red Sox kept rolling with the bonus savings, dropping third round money (pick #93 value) on tenth rounder Kaleb LaFavor to keep him from an Iowa commitment. Besides being a pitcher, he is a very similar prospect to third rounder Jace Mataczynski as a raw, projectable, athletic prep from the Upper Midwest. LaFavor presently sits in the low 90's and touches 96 at peak, coming in with some running action if overall average movement. The pitch plays up because he creates a low launch angle with good extension, jumping out of his hand with zip that plays above his velocity even without big movement. He spins a sweeping slider that often gets soft in the upper 70's, though his better ones tighten up in the low 80's and show nice promise. He adds a changeup to round things out, giving him a really nice three pitch mix for a cold weather, small town arm. For LaFavor, the big draw is the projection. The 6'7" righty moves well on the mound with an easy delivery that really gets the ball going out in front, and he's repeating it better than in the past to show solid command. Boston will likely bring him along slowly, letting him build up muscle (he still hasn't crossed 200 pounds despite his height) and add several ticks of velocity both to his fastball and his slider. As he continues to refine his offspeed stuff and get stronger, the Sioux City native has a shot to be a real weapon in Boston's rotation down the line.
Slot value: up to $150,000. Signing bonus: $250,000 ($100,000 against bonus pool).
My rank: unranked. MLB Pipeline: unranked. ESPN: unranked.
Slot value: up to $150,000. Signing bonus: $190,000 ($40,000 against bonus pool).
My rank: unranked. MLB Pipeline: unranked. ESPN: unranked.
The Red Sox spent the last of their bonus pool on Jase Evangelista, a well travelled arm with some upside. He began his career at Washington, where he had mixed results over two years in the bullpen before transferring to UNLV. While his 6.17 ERA left some to be desired, his 30.5% strikeout rate and deep arsenal impressed the staff at Texas A&M and he committed to pitch for the Aggies in 2027. He impressed the Red Sox as well, who bought him out for a little extra cash over the typical fourteenth round pick. Evangelista sits in the low to mid 90's and touches 97 with his fastball, a four seamer with strong riding action. He can turn it over into a solid cutter, turn over a little more into a sweeper, or drop it into a 12-6 curveball. A changeup gives him a fifth pitch, making for a deep arsenal with many options to attack hitters. His command has taken a step forward as well, giving hime every chance to pitch out of the rotation in pro ball despite spending his college career as a long reliever. Boston will play with the deep array of pitch shapes to work the Southern California native into a back-end starter.